The Black Informant

African-American culture, news commentary, politics

Rhythm and Bull*&^%?: The Slow Decline of R&B

This is part one of a three part series from the website popmatters.com. Here is an excerpt.

==============

Still others such as Stephanie Mills, Frankie Beverly and Maze, Jeffrey Osborne, Anita Baker, Peobo Bryson, Atlantic Starr, Kashif, Loose Ends, Alexander O’Neal, The Whispers, Kenny “Babyface” Edmonds, and Chaka Khan (post Rufus) helped give R&B a cohesive sound in the early 1980s. As R&B was about attracting upscale “urban” audiences — whether legitimate members of the black middle class or working class strivers — it was by definition a genre targeted to mature audiences. As the 1980s progressed R&B was increasingly out of touch with a generation of black youth consumers, who felt little need to distance themselves from the realities of the Jim Crow era, especially as they faced down the venomous edge of the Reagan era. In real terms the R&B world was being challenged by the embryonic sounds of hip-hop for the attention (and disposable income) of “urban” audiences. A telling sign was the success of Chaka Khan’s remake of Prince’s “I Feel for You” (1984), which featured an opening rap by Melle Mel (technically the first hip-hop and R&B collaboration, though in my mind Jody Whatley’s “Friends”, which was blessed by Rakim, is more significant.) The song remains Khan’s best-selling single. Khan’s version of “I Feel for You” began a tenuous relationship between R&B and hip-hop, one which would finally earn hip-hop validation from the black mainstream and ultimately render R&B irrelevant. (more…)

=========

I have tried to keep this opinion under wraps in public in fear of sounding “too old”, but I think this article adds some validity to a growing opinion—R&B is just not the same anymore.

Weather it’s the fault of the industry, or the crop of entertainers out there, man it’s just not the same anymore. I would also say that trend also bleeds into the gospel music industry as well (something that I am itching to write about in the near future).

When I do get a chance to listen to morning radio shows in my local area, I mainly listen to them for the comic relief from the d.j’s. and to catch up on some community news. Beyond that, I just turn to the next station as soon as the music comes on. I’m sorry, but the “lick me”/”suck me” songs just aren’t a good way to start my day–hence the reason why I invested in a 30 Gig mp3 player where I can listen to my own music and podcasts I may have downloaded from the net. From time to time, I do listen to a 70’s/80’s soul music station which I like very much.

My wife had me in stitches one evening as we were flipping through the channels and stopped at a music video. She blurted out to me, “If I see one more video of a mad black woman throwing someone’s clothes out of the window in slow motion…” You know, she’s right. Most of R&B music today has become somewhat repetitive.

This would be a good time for me to have a podcast as I could demonstrate some of the common “runs” you hear in R&B and Gospel today (this is a in-house joke with our family).

What is really funny to me is to see how many well known hip-hop artist (who are millionaires) play the role as though they are struggling to get by. They do this in the name of “keepin’ it real”. On the flip-side, many of our artists back in the day had very little money, but were still able to work a crowd.

I think the article above is right on target when it suggests that people like Chaka Kahn, Anita Baker, Luther Vandross, James Ingram, etc. were some of the last “mature” R&B artist on the scene back during the late 80’s/ early 90’s.

Then again, maybe I am turning into an old fart.

(side note: You know you are getting old when you are actually considering purchasing that soul Time Life collection from that late night infomercial)

June 30, 2005 - Posted by Duane | Uncategorized | | No Comments

No Comments »

  1. i think i might agree with you…partly. the music isn’t the same–though as a youngin’ I’m not sure if I’m even allowed to say that… but i think for the most part it’s because the majority of my generation just isn’t in to it. and the artists, for the most part, end up doing what they think they need to do to make money. For instance, Toni Braxton started out as a bonafide R&B artist, but after a few years (and a few cosmetic procedures), she shifted into whatever it is she’s doing now… There are however quite a few artists who are still true to R&B: Anthony Hamilton, Angie Stone, Jaguar Wright, Vivian Green (pending this newest release which I’ve yet to hear), Jill Scott, and so on. Unfortunately, my generation–the target consumers–just prefers the breathy, studio enhanced “efforts” of ENTERTAINERS such as Amerie and Ciara. And don’t get me wrong, these entertainers have their place (and they’re even fun to watch sometimes), but it’s not so much about the music anymore…

    Comment by rhythm | June 30, 2005

  2. I love those songs on the soul Time Life collection!

    Comment by Steven J. Kelso Sr. | June 30, 2005

  3. I tend to agree with you rhythm. Yeah, they are exceptional for this crop. We just need more of them in the mainstream. I’m just wondering if we are going to be singing Jaguar songs 15 years from now…

    There was a whole crop of artists back during the 80’s/90’s. Today it seems like they fell off of the map. We’ll see.

    Comment by Duane | June 30, 2005

  4. come to think of it, even babyface has sort of abandoned pure R&B. does anybody remember that neptunes track from his last album? the one where he had that whole hip-hop makeover thing going on? tragic…

    Comment by rhythm | July 1, 2005

Leave a comment