The Black Informant

African-American culture, news commentary, politics

“Are monogamous relationships possible?”

This is a question that model/talk show host/reality TV star Tyra Banks asked recently on a recent episode of her syndicated talk show “The Tyra Banks Show”.

She went on to talk about how in past relationships, it was the guy whom she was dating that was unfaithful. She also talked about how she would cry herself to sleep on many nights because it always left her wondering if a monogamous relationship was even possible or existed.

Question:How could a guy find himself wanting to cheat on such a beautiful woman as Tyra Banks?

Answer: A heart that is un-bridled leads to a person that lacks commitment.

The two things that are very telling about Tyra’s question are A. The unfortunate fact that she and others have to ask such a question, and B. The general forgetfulness by our generation that at one time in American history, monogamy was not only the acceptable norm, but it was celebrated.

In decades past we lived in a society that taught our young women to aspire to find that one special “Mr. Right”, get married, have children, and live happily ever after. Even in early childhood, girls were given dolls to reinforce that expectancy of a monogamous relationship within marriage: A “grown-up” doll (Barbie and others similar dolls of that type) who oftentimes had a significant other or husband, or a baby doll (reinforced motherhood). This was not so with boys. In all of my years playing with my GI Joe toys, I never once remember this male “doll” having a picture of a wife or kids included in his weapon-laden backpack. The only other male “doll” at that time was Ken, and quite frankly I never knew of any boys that played with him (or at least willing to admit it). To us boys, Ken was seen as too soft and domesticated (and besides, what boy would want to play with a male doll where the highlight of his (Ken’s) existence was riding as a passenger in Barbie’s pink Corvette?). As you can see, the message to young men that marriage is boring and uneventful is something that is communicated at a very young age.

While young girls were taught the importance of taking care of their man and the importance of giving him undying support, the same lesson was not taught fully to young men (at least on the general level). Boys with an active and healthy relationship with their father in most cases are given the abbreviated talk on marriage: Work hard and stay out of trouble. Although these are two important points, many of our forefathers who were committed and faithful have failed to grant us access to the much needed and desired technical information on how to stay faithful to one woman to the future generation of men. By nature, men want to know how things work. God has such a sense of humor because he has given us his greatest and most complicated piece of work: The woman. Unlike the latest and greatest technical gadget, this piece of work takes a lifetime to understand (at least :) ). Not enough men today are willing to make such an investment. Sadly today, a growing number of women are also not willing to make the investment as well. Yes, the responsibility of commitment falls on both man and woman.

It’s simply not enough to prepare a man for marriage by instructing him to be a protector. Men also need to know how to handle themselves in vulnerable situations. Questions like “If I’m married and I encounter another woman that is more beautiful than my wife and she is a better listener, what are some practical steps for me to avoid making a decision that I may regret for the rest of my life?”, or “My wife says she want me to love her tonight, but without sex. Is that possible?” have virtually gone unanswered while generations of men are left to their own vices to come up with their own solutions which oftentimes ends up with disastrous results.

Although I had parents that remained married until my father’s death a few years ago, I still needed the influence and input of other men who had not only remained committed to their wives for years, but were able to practically tell me how I could do the same. The wonderful thing about the married male friends I have been fortunate to have in my life was that although they helped me to identify the “dots”, they allowed me the room to connect the dots on my own. In other words, the steps a man need to take to remain committed to his woman can vary.

As I have mentioned on this site many times, although marriage is not the “cure all” solution to a long and happy relationship, it does set visible boundaries. In a live-in relationship, beyond a simple expressed acknowledgment that the two of you care for each other, there is really nothing binding the two of you together. If something goes wrong, you can just pack up and leave. In most cases there are very little to no financial obligations to worry about. You are two separate individuals. In marriage, you have made a commitment with each other before family, friends, and most importantly, God that you would remain faithful to death do you part (I know some have changed that part of the vows, but that just shows just how far we have drifted). This means no matter what happens (I would add here anything outside of abuse), the two of you are now committed not to bail on each other and work it out. It is this absolute that scares many people away from marriage.

So to answer Tyra’s question, “Yes!” Monogamous relationships are possible and do exist. But I would also add that marriage is the only arena where your chances for a long-lasting relationship with the same person are greatly increased. Anything else and you are making a serious gamble.

November 27, 2005 - Posted by Duane | Uncategorized | | 6 Comments

6 Comments »

  1. Thanks for a wonderful post, Duane.

    Check out Willard Harley’s work for some practical solutions that have helped me in the past: http://www.marriagebuilders.com

    Comment by Julio | November 27, 2005

  2. Great post.

    I would add that not only is a monogamous relationship possible they are in fact needed for a civil society to function at it’s highest potential.

    Comment by Keith | November 27, 2005

  3. What kind of idiot would cheat on Tyra!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Steven J. Kelso Sr. | November 28, 2005

  4. This is a very complicated topic due to the fact that there are so many reasons why monogamous relationships face so much peril. I am glad that people are talking about this topic. I feel that self-image and media influence have a lot to do with the state of love and relationships in black society. Black women have been devalued to the point that Black men (not all black men) treat them like something that is disposable instead of something that should be treasured. Moreover Black women are losing sight of the value in themselves because of such treatment. In short we must find love for ourselves (love the skin we are in) before we can love someone else.

    Comment by Michael Grundy | December 2, 2005

  5. Black women and men are absolultely precious and to be esteemed highly and loved as creations of a God who is competent and loving, and Jesus was not a fool to die on the cross for black women and men or people of any color or race. To devalue a person of any gender or race is to make Jesus out to be a fool and to make God out to be a lousy Creator.

    The fact that Tyra could be cheated on proves with a shadow of doubt that when someone is cheated on, it is not because of any inadequacy in the person being cheated on, but it rests in the lack of backbone, integrity, sincerity, decency, and love of the person doing the cheating. Some people love people and some people merely love the objects of pleasure, comfort, or relief they can get from people, and once those true objects of love move to another person, the love moves with those objects leaving the person behind.

    No, Tyra should not lose hope and expect that all are unfaithful and incapable of monogamy. Tyra deserves better. She deserves a real man and real men don’t cheat.

    I’m sorry, I’m not black, but when I watched Tyra’s show this evening, I felt somewhat sensitive about this issue because my wife was unfaithful to me, and for awhile I also wondered what was wrong with me and wondered what I could do to save the marriage while my wife played the other man against me to have us compete for her affections by giving her what she wanted. It’s totally narcissistic, selfish, immature, infantile and cowardly.

    Anyway, not that it matters, but I’m white and my ex was chinese-indonesian. Four years later I had a wonderful girlfriend who was Filipina, but her family would not approve since I was not Catholic, so the break up hurt, and yet we could see how it worked for the best, and now I have a wonderful girlfriend who is singaporean and we are both desiring to marry one day. But, had we not met, I could never see myself ruling out the possibility of marrying a black woman if she were deeply committed to the Lord.

    Comment by Dan | December 6, 2005

  6. I am divorced, happy successful, black women and I would love to see proof of a monogamous black man. It makes me sad. But I am hopeful.

    Comment by saved sister | July 4, 2007

Leave a comment