The Black Informant

African-American culture, news commentary, politics

Review: Hot Ghetto Mess/We Got to Do Better

Side One

Well after all the snap commentaries and protests and threats of boycotts the night finally came for the show that would doom ALL Black people back to the days when Chicken George roamed the plantation.

The show was a mixture of street interviews, off the wall home videos highlighted by brief comments by host Charlie Murphy. The guy who conducted the street interviews asked questions such as “When did slavery end?”, “What does N.A.A.C.P. stand for?”, “Who is Barack Obama?” and other simple questions that proved to be quite tough for the folks featured on the show (mind you, interviewees consisted of both White and Black individuals). The interviews reminded me of the street interviews that I conducted years ago for various video projects in Atlanta. Trust me when I say that it was not hard to find folks who were not knowledgeable about basic history or current events. In fact, this show favored a combination of America’s Funniest Home Videos and Street Smarts.

The featured videos (which also featured Blacks and Whites doing some really dumb stuff) were as silly as you could imagine. Again, it reminded me of a Black version of America’s Funniest Home Videos (which can be very funny minus the host–which leads me to Side 2).

Side Two

Okay, the following are things that I did not like or would change:

#Charles Murphy’s whole presentation I thought was very…strange to say the least. I did not know if he was trying to be funny or serious most of the time. I dunno, maybe it was his script.

#If he says “We got to do better” one more time…! (speaking of which, when the show states “WE” got to do better, are they talking about Black folks? White folks? Rednecks? Who?

#DEFINITELY change the title of the show. I personally think that the title alone is what threw a lot of folks off on their pre-judgment of the show.

#”Bid ‘em in” was a good short, but it just didn’t ‘fit’ for some reason, IMO.

Bottom line, I think the show does have some potential—just not in its present form.

Conclusion

I think that all the pure hell that was raised over this show was a complete over reaction (especially with Home Depot and State Farm Insurance pulling out as sponsors). As I have said on this site several times already, much of the criticism came out of this fear that when White folks see it, they will feel empowered to perpetuate Black stereotypes (as if some of us have not done a good job doing that without their help). Trust me when I say that this show would not have ‘empowered’ them. Mind you, these are the same Negroes that will laugh their heads off at the dumb actions of a White person on shows like America’s Funniest Home Videos or Jackass, but will feel some level of “shame” if the next clip features the equally dumb antics of a Black person as if this individual was hired to represent the intelligence of an entire race and screwed it up. (yep, I’ve been guilty of that MANY times).

Personally, I think we are long overdue for a Black version of America’s Funniest Home Videos–just without all the social commentary as served in HGM/WGTDB.

[updated 6:36pst]

July 26, 2007 - Posted by Duane | Uncategorized | | 3 Comments

3 Comments »

  1. thanks for the review, I was hoping some one would catch the show since I didn’t. I still don’t think I’d watch it, but at least from what you’ve said it doesn’t sound so bad. I just wonder if Black Entertainment Television can include more positive and intellectual programming. Programming meant to inform and just…where have all the quality Black shows gone? *end rant*

    Anyway, thanks again. :)

    Comment by Storme | July 26, 2007

  2. I have read several reviews and opinions about the show and honestly, I am shocked at what I’ve been reading. Most of the comment’s I’ve read have been negative. But I saw the show and I thought that it was brilliant! Especially, the “Bid’Em In” skit. The writing for that poem/rap was superb. Also, I think it was great that folks were shown how much we really take for granted and how much we really don’t know about our own history. (i.e. “How many Blacks sit on the Supreme Court?” and “What’s the unemployment rate for Black in America?”).

    Here are our options: More rap video’s that have NO redeeming value, OR We can TRY something else. For the longest time I personally have complained about BET’s prgramming. They took the news off (rememeber … 11pm, they had a news program) and traded it for the extra nasty video’s. Also, they showed tons of sitcom re-runs … from our “t.v. glory days” as if NO one is making any thing new and trying to get it aired. Now finally, someone is trying to break the mold … and our feelings are hurt.

    So, here is the deal. We complain about the “Cosby Show”, because “it wasn’t real” … A Black Doctor and a Black Atty married. Nah, we want to “keep it real”. So, we got 20 hours of rap videos and 6 hours of Church on Sunday’s. Black people are much more than that and HGM shows that. It’s not all good, nor is it all bad. It’s not all rap and it’s not all comedy. We have to have balance and this is an attempt at that.

    The show was great and I hope it stays on. Watch it and learn something … even if it’s with a grain of salt.

    Comment by Khalil | July 30, 2007

  3. this post was funny as hell: http://averagebro.blogspot.com/2007/07/better-programming-dont-bet-on-it.html

    Comment by Cube | July 30, 2007

Leave a comment